city: issue 28.5-6

people
cities
struggles
ideas
always... →
Cover Issue
many perspectives
one journal ↴

city: issue 28.5-6

founding editor: bob caterrall

editor: city editors

editorial: Cities, computation and capitalism

alexander tarr

… Metropolis. Great movie. Exactly the world Pökler and evidently quite a few others were dreaming about those days, a Corporate City-state where technology was the source of power, the engineer worked closely with the administrator, the masses labored unseen far underground, and ultimate power lay with a single leader at the top, fatherly and benevolent and just, who wore magnificent-looking suits … (Thomas Pynchon, Gravity’s Rainbow, 1973, 673) 

As I write, over seventy million citizens of the United States have just reelected Donald Trump as their President, along with a cabal of his supporters into all levels of American government. The global ramifications of their return to power threaten to be catastrophic, from hobbling environmental policies meant to save cities from the worst impacts of climate change to nightmarish immigration policies. The post-mortems on what went wrong to put the world’s most infamous, criminal real estate developer back in charge of the world’s largest economy will be arriving for years to come. This piece is not one of them, but others will surely dwell on the explosion of misinformation spread through seemingly uncontrollable digital networks, an attendant culture of grievance, and the specific roles played by the arch-tech-billionaires Elon Musk and Peter Thiel. There is still something incomprehensible, in the literal sense that we do not yet have concepts to comprehend, the assemblage of networked computer technologies, far-right populism, and a new class of corporate owners at the top of the power structure. Incomprehensible, but not surprising.

The first digital computers to emerge at the end of World War II had the processing power of around 1/500,000th of a modern smartphone and were primarily used at first to design weapons for mass murder. In the present moment, as untold breathless articles have begun in recent years, the companies and individuals who own and control systems built on networked computational devices increasingly appear as the most powerful forces shaping everything from the global economy to political systems to the daily lives of everyone on the planet. The analysis of what could generally be called the ‘digital revolution’ over the last 70 years is overflowing with hot takes, mixed metaphors, and what Andrew Sayer (1992) might call ‘bad abstractions’ or ‘chaotic concepts’: terms like ‘High-tech’, ‘Big Tech’, ‘Silicon Valley’, ‘Platforms’, and ‘Stacks’, that fail to recognize necessary relationships. The proliferation of these concepts suggests a sense that the analytic frameworks developed under the entwined systems of capitalism and colonialism may no longer be fit for purpose thanks to the power of networked computers. Indeed, there is a growing debate on the left over whether we still live under Capitalism at all. As McKenzie Wark (2021) asks us, ‘capital is dead, is this something worse?’ The question has profound implications for urban studies as well. We might ask in return ‘if capitalism is dead, what is a post-capitalist city?’

Much of what we understand about urbanism is based on cities in relation to a capitalist mode of production, and all that its historical development entailed. Capitalism has not been the only global system, certainly a great deal of work in this and other urban journals engages with the complexities of post-colonial and post-socialist cities. We have robust debates over the extent to which transformations of those political-economic systems reshape urban life. Post-capitalist cities, however, largely remain in the realm of the speculative, hopeful and, occasionally, prescriptive futures. If we take Wark’s, and others’, assertion that capitalism as we know it has been killed by a digital revolution (akin here to ‘the industrial revolution’), what does it mean to be living in post-capitalist cities? They are clearly not the green utopias that we have dreamed of. Has computation actually killed the capitalist city? It may not yet be an answerable question. However, there is a need at this moment for a mode of research, thinking and organizing that bridges the gap between high-level theories of social transformation and the grounded studies of how the uses of digital technologies are (or are not) changing lived urban conditions. Here, I suggest looking to the debate on the transformative effect of a digitally-oriented economy, and then, to what these developing socio-technical systems mean for urban spaces.

One brief note on terminology before proceeding. Digital urban studies must often think with terms like ‘big data’ and ‘tech companies’, but the underlying relations they describe can become mystified through repetition. I am intentionally using the somewhat unwieldy term ‘networked computation’ throughout as a shorthand for the interwoven socio-technical systems that includes the producers of software (i.e. computer programs, apps, platforms, data processing tools, artificial intelligences, network protocols and encryption tools) and hardware (i.e personal computers, mobile devices, servers, network infrastructure, sensors, weapons, drones, biomedical devices) and their countless uses in cities (see Figure 1). This is to suggest a more fundamental abstraction that points toward what is both unique and unifying in a long digital revolution.

editorial

Cities, computation and capitalism
Figure: SOKA WiFi by Tom Schofield (Citation2024). ‘Everywhere I have never been, except there’ visualizes our phone's connection to WiFi. Using live data from passers-by the work creates hybrid maps based on records found for networks leaked from their phones. www.tomschofield.net.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Cities, computation and capitalism

 … Metropolis. Great movie. Exactly the world Pökler and evidently quite a few others were dreaming about those days, a Corporate City-state where technology was the source of power, the engineer worked closely with the administrator, the masses labored unseen far underground, and ultimate power lay with a single leader at the top, fatherly and benevolent and just, who wore magnificent-looking suits … (Thomas Pynchon, Gravity’s Rainbow, Citation1973, 673)

read on t&f ↗

original articles

It is ‘more than just about building houses’: collaborating towards a housing commons in Leeds
Figure: Frontline self-builders on-site (Photo: Claude Hendrickson).
abstract / preview

Abstract

It is ‘more than just about building houses’: collaborating towards a housing commons in Leeds

While current research focuses on the emergence of community-led housing (CLH) in England and individual cases, including co-operatives and Community Land Trusts, understanding of the breadth of CLH and its contribution to a city-wide commons is limited. We explore the evolution of CLH-as-commoning in the city of Leeds through three time periods and a framework of ‘differential’ and ‘transitional’ commoning, attentive to relations, spatiality and governance, and multiple contested visions from minimalist to maximalist. There was a maximalist tendency in the 1970s/80s, minimalist into the 1990s, and maximalist-pragmatist in the 2000s/10s. More significantly, we highlight the important role that minimalist and pragmatist tendencies play in the ongoing growth of the commons and commoners. CLH is part of a growing urban commons if we see it built through a patchwork of different approaches and actors, all contributing to cumulative horizon building. The transformative potential of CLH-as-commoning lies in repeated attempts to challenge the current housing system. More needs to be done to support long term collaboration between civil society and the state to widen involvement, expand provision and support democratic benefits of CLH.

read on t&f ↗
Making the state care: the role of political willingness and brokerage in Bogota’s new feminist care policy
Figure: Care Blocks location map and criteria (Source: Secretaría de la Mujer, Alcaldía de Bogotá Citation2022).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Making the state care: the role of political willingness and brokerage in Bogota’s new feminist care policy

This article examines the crucial role of political willingness and brokerage in the implementation of Bogotá's new feminist care policy, the ‘System of Care', which aims to address gender and class inequalities and alleviate care burdens on women. Through a combination of ethnographic data and stakeholder interviews, we analyze the intricate political and social processes that underpin the policy's effectiveness. Drawing on academic literature about care work, policy implementation in weak states, and brokerage, we provide a comprehensive understanding of the policy's development and operation, from the inception of the System of Care to its day-to-day functionality within the local Care Blocks. Our findings underscore the significance of political willingness and brokerage at the macro level, along with the importance of debureaucratization and trust-building at the micro level, as key factors contributing to the policy’s success. Yet, the policy innovation also faces several challenges, primarily political uncertainties and the risk of burnout among local Care Block coordinators.

read on t&f ↗
Version city:            Small Axe            , London and the archive
Figure: 1970s Front Room at Museum of the Home - Image credit Gifty Dzenyo.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Version city: Small Axe , London and the archive

Small Axe, directed by Steve McQueen for BBC / Amazon Studios, was released in the UK and US over Autumn-Wintser 2021/22. Across five films it acknowledges events and records experiences of African Caribbean populations in London during the 1970s and 1980s. Drawing upon semi-structured interviews with members of the production team and mise-en-scène analysis, our aim is to understand how Small Axe contributes to the production of urban history by drawing upon archives and repurposing a cinematic archive for future use. It is an example of what Hal Foster calls ‘archival art’. The first part of our analysis, on poiesis, considers the archival work carried out in the production of Small Axe; the second, on aisthesis, contemplates the anthology’s configuration of a specific space and its framing of a particular sphere of experience. Our argument is that Small Axe constitutes a ‘versioning’ of London’s post-WWII black history, a recombination of archival elements into a new sensorial archive. The concept of ‘version’ is taken from dub reggae and refers to new takes on, or versions of, pre-written and recorded tracks, involving innovative levels of modification and creative interpretation and/or translation for new audiences.

read on t&f ↗
Community action, counter-professionals and radical planning in the UK
"Harold Wilson meeting locals of Washington, UK (late 1960s)" by Tyne & Wear Archives & Museums, Wikimedia Commons (No known copyright restrictions).

community action, counter-professionals and radical planning in the uk

andy inch, j. slade, s. brownill, g. ellis, m. howcroft, d. humphry, l. leeson, g. o’hara, f. sartorio, g. robbins

keywords: planning, community, professionalism, direct action, empowerment

abstract / preview

Abstract

Community action, counter-professionals and radical planning in the UK

This paper reconsiders the roles of ‘counter-professionals’ (Goodman 1972) in urban social movements, focusing on the generation of students, activists and planners involved in the UK’s community action movement from the late-1960s. The paper therefore provides the first historical account of the ways community action stimulated the development of a distinctive counter-tradition of radical planning in the UK, inspiring experimentation with new, activist roles amongst a generation of young professionals who sought to support community-based movements seeking to challenge the post-war state, develop new models of participatory planning and lay the foundations for a more democratic society. Drawing on oral history interviews with key figures and archival materials from their personal records coupled with analysis of Community Action magazine (1972–1990), we track how many of those involved developed careers ‘working the spaces of power’ in and against various state projects (Newman 2012). The paper explores three key, interconnected dimensions of our participants’ experiences that we argue are central to counter-professional practice and the politics of radical planning: their relations with the state; their relations with community-based movements and organisations; and thirdly, the ways these relations shaped the political horizons of community action. Our empirical work concludes by accounting for the relative decline of community action in the 1980s. Through reconsideration of the UK context, the paper contributes to debates about the politics of radical planning and the roles of activist-professionals within urban social movements. It concludes with reflection on the seemingly constrained conditions of possibility for counter-professional practices today and the wider lessons of the community action moment for attempts to build collective alternatives, in, against and beyond the neoliberal state. By reconsidering the role of radical planners in community action in the UK we hope the paper can inspire further debate about the contributions future generations of counter-professionals might make to ongoing movements for urban justice, both in the UK and internationally.

read on t&f ↗
From the            sthala purana            to the novel: Sethu’s            The Saga of Muziris            as a narrative geography of the ancient Indian port city of Muziris
"Chinese fishing nets found in Fort Cochin, Kerala" by Challiyil Eswaramangalath Vipin, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

From the sthala purana to the novel: Sethu’s The Saga of Muziris as a narrative geography of the ancient Indian port city of Muziris

The narrative approach to city writing in the postcolonial world gravitates towards metropolitan spaces. The discourse around how these cities are imagined and theorized uses reference points from modernity. With the emergence of the spatial turn in literary theory and criticism, this discourse borrows from Western, postmodern sensibilities to define cities and their narrative possibilities. In contrast to these sensibilities, regional variations of practising narrative geography that are non-Western and pre-modern reveal a heightened sense of territorial consciousness and a claim towards mythological origins posing as history. One of these genres is that of the pre-modern genre of the sthala purana from India. This article seeks to foreground it as a geographical narrative of individual locales within India. We argue that it is a genre that opens up fascinating possibilities for the exploration of cities outside postcolonial metropolises so that such spaces can be understood on their own terms rather than being compared to the big city as if it were a paradigm. We focus on one Kochi (a city in Kerala) novel by Sethu, The Saga of Muziris to explicate the knowledge-making about cities at work in such narrative geography in the way it invokes Kochi’s ancestor of the ancient port city of Muziris.

read on t&f ↗
No space to share. Challenges of accommodating grassroots initiatives in sustainable urban districts
Figure: Visions image of part of Masthuggskajen © SWECO/Göteborgs Stad.
abstract / preview

Abstract

No space to share. Challenges of accommodating grassroots initiatives in sustainable urban districts

Many cities in the Global North that aspire to be at the forefront of sustainable urbanism have adopted Sharing City agendas. In the development of socially inclusive cities, grassroots sharing initiatives have been seen as key in disseminating more sustainable forms of provisioning. This article examines a case where ambitions to accommodate grassroots sharing initiatives failed, namely in the renewal of the sustainability and sharing-branded area of Masthuggskajen in Gothenburg, Sweden. In order to analyse the interactions and power relations between governance bodies and grassroots sharing initiatives, and how these are shaped by spatial dimensions, we explore the opportunities for grassroots initiatives to influence sustainability goals in the development of high-profile urban districts. Our findings suggest that while areas branded as sharing economy districts acknowledge the potential of grassroots initiatives, high rents precipitate the displacement or co-optation of non-commercial actors, thereby preventing deeper transformation. In more peripheral areas, grassroots initiatives are more likely to thrive, but often fail to reach beyond a critical niche. In order for grassroots sharing initiatives to influence the meanings and practices of sustainability, this spatial paradox, we argue, calls for political solutions at both the local and national level.

read on t&f ↗
Ecology of urban decay. Unintentional landscapes of enhanced biodiversity in Rome
"View of Caffarella Park, Rome" by Notafly, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Ecology of urban decay. Unintentional landscapes of enhanced biodiversity in Rome

This research explores the relationship between urban environments and unintentional landscapes in Rome, emphasizing the significance of spontaneous nature within the city’s cultural narrative. To do so, it empirically hypothesizes that the temporal dimension, considering the historical context, plays a crucial role in shaping public acceptance and legitimization of these landscapes. By drawing on urban ecology experiences from Central Europe, the research aims to provide a modern interpretation of unintentional landscapes as valuable urban planning tools for Rome. Rome has many gardens, parks, and villas, but it also has a unique relationship with spontaneous nature, a phenomenon that is deeply rooted in the cultural narrative. It is visible in a number of historical engravings, paintings, and academic studies, which illustrate the intricate interactions between urban neglect and the unintentional landscapes. These landscapes contribute to a diffuse and heterogeneous natural fabric that enhances the ecological potential of today’s existing green spaces. The paper posits that, over time, spontaneous nature has blurred the boundaries between the natural and built environments, fostering a paradigm of coexistence that promotes a more-than-human city.

read on t&f ↗
‘They’re not dog friendly because they’re not anyone friendly’: living with dogs in two densifying London neighbourhoods
Figure: Billboard covering a new London development construction site, showcasing contemporary city living that includes dogs. Authors’ own, 2024.
abstract / preview

Abstract

‘They’re not dog friendly because they’re not anyone friendly’: living with dogs in two densifying London neighbourhoods

Since the late 1990s, policy makers in the UK have promoted building higher density housing. Notably absent from this policy are the companion animals with whom we share our homes and public spaces. Their absence is all the more surprising given that dog companionship is often associated with the same outcomes as championed by the density and compact city agendas—social cohesion, community well-being, and active lifestyles. Based on research conducted in two London neighbourhoods, this paper explores how people experience urban density when with a dog, the challenges and opportunities they encounter, and how they negotiate their way through an often confusing and unspoken web of rules, laws and norms. The research builds on work which examines human-dog relations, arguing that the lack of clarity around where dogs are and are not welcome is reflective of the ways dogs are ambiguously positioned in relation to discourses of density and urban living. The ways urbanism is promoted in the UK is not politically neutral, nor are the ways some dogs are included or excluded from this imagining. We argue that the absence of clarity about dogs is constitutive of shifting and often confusing discourses about animals, urbanism, and densification.

read on t&f ↗
Representing London: making and claiming the city
"Chamber of the London Assembly" by Cabinetkey, Wikimedia Commons (CC0 1.0).

representing london: making and claiming the city

karim murji, susannah cramer-greenbaum, edanur yazici, michael keith, steve pile, john solomos

keywords: democracy, governance, politics, vision, imaginaries

abstract / preview

Abstract

Representing London: making and claiming the city

What does it mean to represent a city? We examine this question through drawing from and seeking to read across two somewhat distinct meanings of representation, stemming from cultural theory and political studies. The reason for approaching representation in this way is an interest in how elected representatives claim the city. Based on interviews with members of the London Assembly, we take a transversal cut across party and geographical lines to analyse the nature and content of their representative claims, identifying two main types: the city as an identity and as a place or a collection of places. The politicians invoke cultural and institutional dimensions of representation and representativeness. The usefulness of employing both senses of representation is that through its representatives, the city—and urban democratic representation—is more than a discrete object or even a multiplicity of viewpoints, but rather a process continually made and remade through practices and claims, even as these slide across scales. These repertoires of representation, of the city as is and as it could be, signal how even from a place of seeming political marginality, the city is open to multiple imagined ideals that are shared and cut across conventional political lines.

read on t&f ↗
Human sensors in the city of super apps: mobilizing people as infrastructure for smart city development in Jakarta, Indonesia
"Jakarta Traffic" by aenertia, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Human sensors in the city of super apps: mobilizing people as infrastructure for smart city development in Jakarta, Indonesia

In this paper, we argue that contextual factors such as the availability of infrastructure, sociocultural characteristics of users, governance style, and the regulatory environment in global south cities create opportunities for public and private sector actors to come up with innovative strategies for smart city development and the platformization of services. Despite different objectives, operationalization strategies, and expected outcomes between the public and private sectors, both sectors learn from one another to come up with innovative solutions for navigating contextual contingencies. Due to limited infrastructure and contextual diversities in global south cities, digital platforms require significant and specific forms of groundwork by humans that leverage their everyday networks and interactions with their surroundings. In the process of platformization, both governments and private entities strategically employ the discourse of smart, responsible citizenship to promote the innovative co-creation of platform services, thereby extending biopolitical control over citizens’ bodies and interactions. In this process, citizens are engaged as sensing nodes to support smart city development in global south cities. This paper examines two distinct cases of public and private sector ‘human sensing’ experiments in Jakarta: Jakarta Smart City’s JakLapor platform and Grab's human mapping initiative. In these experiments, ‘peopled collaborations’ (Simone 2021) between citizens are deployed by the government and the platform company as innovations where urban infrastructure is inadequate, or to fill gaps that cannot be filled by conventional digital infrastructure.

read on t&f ↗
The production of information space in the port of Piraeus: digital logistical media, power mutations and state transformations
"Bird's eye view of Piraeus Port, Greece" by Cristo Vlahos, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

The production of information space in the port of Piraeus: digital logistical media, power mutations and state transformations

Since 2010 the container terminal of Piraeus has—under the management of the Chinese operator COSCO Shipping—established itself as a hub in the global supply chains as well as a critical node in China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). The sharp increase in container handling volumes, and the terminal’s further interconnection with dozens more ports, have helped turn Piraeus into a global infrastructure. The article commences from an understanding of the port as an anomalous space where heterogeneous and overlapping powers, jurisdictions, actors and interests articulate and at times clash. It then turns to the port’s ongoing digitalisation and introduces the concept of ‘information space’ to explain the ways that information reflects and reproblematises the governance of Piraeus. More specifically, it focuses on the launch of a digital platform for the exchange of information between port users and the coordination of its operations. By interrogating the frictions and turbulent negotiations that followed the platform’s introduction, the paper explores the political, economic, and geographical transformations associated with the emergence of information as a key spatial agent.

read on t&f ↗
A new urbanity in a suburban region: the perceived (im)possibilities of light rail among residents and stakeholders in Canada’s Waterloo Region
"ION LRV 506 approaches Fairway Station, June 24 2019" by Jason897, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

A new urbanity in a suburban region: the perceived (im)possibilities of light rail among residents and stakeholders in Canada’s Waterloo Region

Recent scholarship on light rail transit (LRT) connects this infrastructure to broader processes of urban transformation, bringing to the forefront its significance beyond transportation functionality. However, much of the transportation literature does not adequately explore light rail’s diverse meanings. In this article, we draw on 65 semi-structured interviews with residents living along the new LRT line in Waterloo Region, Canada, as well as 20 key stakeholders, to identify the infrastructure’s perceived roles with respect to city building, urban identity, and neighbourhood change. We investigate how residents ascribe meaning to the LRT, and the extent to which these meanings align with stakeholders’ growth management objectives. In contrast to this focused planning rationale, the LRT evokes for residents a broader range of (im)possibilities that reflect their class positions and understandings of (sub)urban life in the region. Residents’ perspectives underline light rail’s implication in producing middle-class urbanity beyond its role in supporting an intensified, revitalized urban form. Here, light rail also reinforces existing urban middle-class identities and aspirations, which conflict with both dominant suburban identities and the experiences and fears of lower-income residents living along the route. These findings interrogate who is included in the type of city an LRT helps construct.

read on t&f ↗
Flânerie, virtual-mobilized gaze and urban experience in Abbas Kirasotami’s            The Experience            (1973)
"Tehran street scene 1974" by Dick Gilbert, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Flânerie, virtual-mobilized gaze and urban experience in Abbas Kirasotami’s The Experience (1973)

This article offers an analysis of one of Abbas Kiarostami’s lesser-known films, The Experience. Focusing on the urban experience of its young protagonist, against the backdrop of Tehran during the height of Mohammad Reza Pahlavi's urbanization project, the film is examined for its treatment of urban attractions, consumer-culture, and the boy’s interaction with them as a young immigrant in modern Tehran. The study highlights Kiarostami’s deviation from typical critiques of the modern city with a moralist standpoint which was prevalent at the time, presenting a nuanced exploration of the urban experience of its subject. The Experience can be seen as a microcosm of the broader encounter many Iranian urbanites had with modernity and consumer culture, embodied in Mohammad’s journey from naive hope to actualize the images presented to him to the eventual realization of his socioeconomic realities. The film portrays his interaction with the city through flânerie and employment of a virtual-mobilized gaze. This gaze becomes an agent for the transformative impact of urban visual culture, as it replaces the reality with a virtual world of commodities. The article positions The Experience as a seminal piece in Iranian cinema, highlighting Kiarostami's representation of the subjective experience of an individual within modern Tehran.

read on t&f ↗

special feature: comparison and community engagement: post-politics meets post-colony and state-entrepreneurialism

Comparison and community engagement: post-politics meets post-colony and state entrepreneurialism. Introduction to the special feature
"Public meeting for the beachfront redevelopment at Wasaga Beach (June 2024)" by Transportfan70, Wikimedia Commons (CC0 1.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Comparison and community engagement: post-politics meets post-colony and state entrepreneurialism. Introduction to the special feature

Rapid urban growth and ubiquitous experiences of extending and dispersed urban forms give rise to new territories of urban politics, including large-scale developments which have significant impacts on communities. Given the commitment that many urban scholars have to community based and social justice-oriented research, the possibility to build understandings of these developments from the perspective of community-based actors is a high priority. But comparative analysis and theory-building across diverse community experiences presents methodological and analytical challenges. This introduction presents a collection of papers which initiated comparative analyses of community engagements in large-scale urban developments on three grounds. Firstly, allowing understandings from one urban context to ‘speak’ to another in an open comparative strategy provided a framework for activist and practitioner-led analysis including direct learning between practitioners. Secondly, new trajectories of reading literature from each context into the others disrupted the hegemony of northern theoretical approaches. And, thirdly, collaborative comparative empirical analyses of community engagement in large-scale urban developments extended the range of more formal insights on urban governance and community-based politics across three diverse contexts. Notably, papers in this collection emphasize consensus-building and collaboration alongside negotiation and contestation, all expanding community-based ‘voice’ and presence within urban politics.

read on t&f ↗
The Grand Union Alliance: community-based networking as response to large-scale urban development
"The Heygate Estate in the process of demolition, from Elephant & Castle station" by Christopher Hilton / Geograph Britain and Ireland, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

The Grand Union Alliance: community-based networking as response to large-scale urban development

Large-scale developments in London often have negative impacts on less well-off communities as they include: demolition of social-rented homes, low levels of new social-rented homes, over-development of luxury housing, loss of existing local industry and replacement of jobs, services and infrastructure that fail to meet the needs of existing low-income communities. However, residents, especially deprived or excluded working class communities, don’t generally engage in the technical and alien language of the planning policy impacting on large-scale developments taking place across London. This paper, written by two community organisers and a researcher, discusses the organising model whereby the Grand Union Alliance, a large network of around 250 groups, individuals and small businesses was gradually developed. The consensus model of working, developed over many years in the Just Space setting, allowed shared positions to come forward across different interests, and supported extensive community-based contributions to the planning process, with some success in influencing planning policy. The paper shares this model of organising, together with some of the challenges and outcomes, in the hope of informing other initiatives to engage with large-scale urban developments across London, and elsewhere.

read on t&f ↗
Planned            stitching            , practical            suturing            : assembling community voices and mobilisation across difference in Johannesburg’s corridors of freedom
Figure: Snapshot of one of one of the breakaway focus group sessions during a cross-neighbourhood stakeholder meeting. PC: Planact, October 2017.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Planned stitching , practical suturing : assembling community voices and mobilisation across difference in Johannesburg’s corridors of freedom

The City of Johannesburg’s Corridors of Freedom (CoF), launched in 2013, were intended to cut across the economically and racially divided city using infrastructure and interventions in the built environment around new transport nodes. Undertaken in haste for political reasons and projected to be delivered as swiftly as possible, those driving this mega project oversaw substantial consultation exercises, but provided relatively few spaces for direct engagement to shape the project. This paper presents the experiences of a team of engaged-researchers, a long-standing NGO in partnership with University-based scholars jointly investigating the CoF development process. Interested in the ways in which the CoF initiative sought to ‘stitch’ the city together, our contribution to the project was to engage with different communities, clarify their different experiences with participation in the Corridors development and explore the possibility of collaboration across these different communities. Using the conceptual framework of stitching and suturing, the paper, in two parts, interrogates the roles that engaged partners can have in complex and diverse communities and our ability to support engagement. We reveal the limitations of engaged research when faced with political and institutional cycles that do not synchronise with the research projects, and point to the cleavages and disruptions that result when the local state does not systematically incorporate the needs and lived realities of its residents.

read on t&f ↗
Mobilising in the face of large-scale urban change: a conversation between two community organisers from Johannesburg and London
"Winstanley Estate Regeneration proposed plan" by Kip1234, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Mobilising in the face of large-scale urban change: a conversation between two community organisers from Johannesburg and London

Large-scale and long-term urban development projects often cause sizeable transformations in the built and social fabric, raising questions about the impacts on existing neighbourhoods and communities, and how they might try to shape the development. There are significant challenges to achieving community-based engagement at a large scale involving mobilising a wide range of stakeholders with different positionalities, agendas and priorities across multiple and diverse areas of a city. In this interview, two experienced organisers reflect together on their different but resonant experiences in building community networks to engage with large-scale developments. Between 2016 and 2018, the research project ‘Governing the Future City’ explored the governance of large-scale developments in three urban areas—London, Johannesburg and Shanghai. In Johannesburg and London, the research process directly funded and supported community-based organising in relation to the planning and implementation of the developments. The organisers and researchers worked with existing community-based organisations to try to influence the planning process, drawing together a wide range of affected community and neighbourhood groups.

read on t&f ↗
Towards the                    desired                    city of compromise: the politics of negotiating large-scale transformation across diversity in Johannesburg
"Rea Vaya stop in Johannesburg CBD" by Keizers, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Towards the desired city of compromise: the politics of negotiating large-scale transformation across diversity in Johannesburg

How to reinvent Johannesburg, a metropolis whose geography of inequality has remained stubbornly entrenched since the end of apartheid? By launching the ‘Corridors of Freedom’ (CoF) initiative in 2013, the municipal government decided to take bold and deliberate steps towards conceiving and promoting a more inclusive and people-centred city. The goal was to disrupt the prevailing spatial and social pattern by connecting different parts of the city via a large public transit network and altering these same areas through increased levels of (affordable) accommodation, density, and mixed-use development. Cutting across the existing urban fabric and affecting a significant number of distinct neighbourhoods, both in terms of socio-economic and racial characteristics, this ambitious project, unsurprisingly, triggered a wide spectrum of reactions. To successfully embed this initiative required securing support (or countering opposition) from both the majority poor and black electorate demanding accessible housing and jobs, and the highly mobilised middle-class groups on whom the City authorities were financially dependent. Taking the CoF public participation process as analytical entry point, we reflect on the diverse power relations of ‘building consensus’ across highly divided neighbourhoods and populations to take forward this large-scale urban transformation.

read on t&f ↗
Settings of community engagement: beyond the Janus-faced post-political in ‘neoliberalised’ London
"Construction of HS2 Old Oak Common station" by David Hawgood / Geograph Britain and Ireland, Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Settings of community engagement: beyond the Janus-faced post-political in ‘neoliberalised’ London

Drawing on an in-depth analysis of the politics of a large-scale urban development in London, as part of a wider comparative project, this paper reconsiders the post-political conclusions of an earlier round of research on large scale developments in Europe. Through a critical re-reading of Jacques Rancière’s analysis and attending to insights from wider accounts of urban politics from the majority urban world, including our own comparative research on Johannesburg and Shanghai, the paper considers the potential of political contestation and engagement. Concepts such as ‘insurgent citizens’, the ‘arts of citizenship’, and the multiple roles of the state, provide focus for a nuanced assessment of the achievements and potential of residents’ and wider community engagements in planning in the case of Old Oak, north-west London. First designated as an ‘Opportunity Area’ and then a Mayoral Development Corporation, substantial investment has been made by the Mayor of London in stimulating development around the site of a new High Speed Train station at Old Oak. Community mobilisation took the form of a network of existing organisations and residents across a large area, encompassing a diverse population and including large swathes of railway and industrial land, making connections were hard to forge. The ambition of the Mayoral Development Corporation created a range of different settings for progressing planning and development, from open engagements with communities over planning visions, to informal and restricted discussions of development applications, secretive master planning initiatives, and highly legalistic procedures of formal inspection. Disaggregating the unitary assessment of politics embedded in post-political analysis, the paper identifies the series of ‘settings’ in which different combinations of political openings, closures and opportunities for advancing concerns of community-based movements can be located. The analysis signposts scope for a more targeted political ambition, based on a community-based strategic assessment of the fragmentation of planning practice. Notably, the negotiations to determine planning gain between planners and developers were identified by the community groups as crucial to shaping development outcomes, with the growing demand to open these to public scrutiny.

read on t&f ↗
Bargaining state-society relationships under state entrepreneurialism: community engagement beyond the resettlement process in Shanghai
Figure: Former homes of residents who successfully demanded for resettlement.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Bargaining state-society relationships under state entrepreneurialism: community engagement beyond the resettlement process in Shanghai

Community engagement in China is mostly understood as absent, tokenistic and characterised by the state’s carrot and stick model of compensation and repression. Drawing on Shanghai Lingang and by looking beyond the process of resettlement, I demonstrate instances where residents can bargain and force concessions from the state and influence development outcomes. To ensure social stability, Lingang’s resettled residents are offered compensation. However, collective mobilisation arises when the state is unable to resettle residents who request it, ultimately forcing the state to resettle residents despite making financial losses. Secondly, township governments in charge of pacifying resident resistance sometimes act on behalf of residents if their interests overlap such as demanding for more investments into the area. Finally, resettlement has cultivated a longer-term dependence of residents on Lingang’s development. However, the state’s promise of sharing the prosperity of growth also lends legitimacy to residents to demand provisions of public amenities and state investments. Through Lingang, I show that the challenge for Chinese the state is to ensure continued economic growth to fund its social stability and that urban development is also driven by non-economic objectives which to some extent enables substantive community engagement albeit unequally and with major caveats.

read on t&f ↗

scenes sounds action

The emerging peri-urban landscape of modern public rental housing towers in China: a case of Chongqing
Figure: The emerging peri-urban landscape of public rental housing in China, 2018. Photo by Weijie Hu.
abstract / preview

Abstract

The emerging peri-urban landscape of modern public rental housing towers in China: a case of Chongqing

This photo essay explores the impact of the rapid expansion of public rental housing in China on the peri-urban landscape. As China tries to cope with rapid urbanisation, public rental housing has become critical in the urban landscape, especially in the sub-urban areas of major cities. The paper criticises the design and planning practices that have resulted in uniform high-rise complexes. It highlights the mismatch between the quantitative achievements in housing provision and the qualitative aspects of urban living, pointing out the lack of human scale and cultural integration in these developments. The essay also features photographs that provide visual evidence of the emerging landscape, characterised by standardised and inaccessible spaces that prioritise regulatory compliance over resident well-being. It identifies a potential future crisis in social sustainability, drawing parallels with issues encountered in Western public rental housing. We argue for a shift towards a more human-centric approach, calling for planning reforms to prioritise cultural context, resident interaction, and community building.

read on t&f ↗
Resisting dark tourism: Northern Cyprus’s ‘ghost city’ of Varosha
Figure: A police officer on scooter patrols Varosha at sunset. Photo: Samuel Holleran.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Resisting dark tourism: Northern Cyprus’s ‘ghost city’ of Varosha

The specter of new global conflicts has brought up old questions about dark tourism: is it ever appropriate to visit recent ruins? Can ruins, and places where violence has occurred, teach lessons about peace and cooperation? Or is it merely war voyeurism? This piece considers the ruins of Varosha (a beachfront district of Famagusta, or Gazimağusa, in Turkish) a once thriving tourism hub which has been walled off from visitors since the Turkish invasion of Cyprus in 1974. The invasion, and the creation of the largely-unrecognized state of Northern Cyprus, was preceded by years of interethnic tension between Turkish- and Greek-Cypriot communities. Recently, the government has reopened the destroyed city, forcing peace activists and urbanists to consider what role these ruins play in conflict resolution and in claims for space.

read on t&f ↗
What is the value in an empty home? A perspective from Action on Empty Homes and the Global Empty Homes Network
Figure: An empty home in the village of Utterslev, Lolland, Denmark. Image courtesy of Jesper Ole Jensen.
abstract / preview

Abstract

What is the value in an empty home? A perspective from Action on Empty Homes and the Global Empty Homes Network

We face a global crisis of housing vacancy: more and more homes are being left to stand empty, whether as part of speculative investment practices or as the fallout of spatial shifts in capital and production. At the same time, access to safe and affordable housing is becoming increasingly scarce. Addressing the contradicting vacancy and scarcity of housing is among the core aims of the Global Empty Homes Network (GEHN), a consortium of advocates and researchers formed in 2021 by the English campaigning charity Action on Empty Homes. Examining the empty homes crisis through a global lens helps to link together analysis of global economic structures with understanding of the diverse ways in which value is generated in empty homes around the world. This article provides an overview of GEHN’s main areas of work, attending to key themes such as real estate speculation, rural depopulation, value and commodification, data quality, and campaigns against empty homes.

read on t&f ↗

reviews

city: analysis of urban change, theory, action journal and website provide a conduit for critical academic debates and theoretical development, considering their implications for everyday lives, urban change and action.