city: issue 29.1-2

people
cities
struggles
ideas
always... →
Cover Issue
many perspectives
one journal ↴

city: issue 29.1-2

editor: city editors

editorial: there is no alternative to creating an alternative: critical urban studies in the authoritarian moment

david madden

“reactionary authoritarianism also draws on the more repressive versions of urban politics that came before it by incorporating a distinctly revanchist spatial imaginary. it defines itself in opposition to a deeply racialized picture of cityness imagined as heterogeneous, unruly and ungovernable.”

as we finish preparing this issue for publication, donald trump is entertaining the prospect of ethnically cleansing gaza and turning it into a ghoulish luxury resort. domestically, his administration is working tirelessly to incapacitate the state, terrorize significant segments of america’s urban population, and ultimately unleash a wave of repression within american cities. in other places where they have come to power, authoritarian governments are violently cracking down on opposition movements, pushing through extreme austerity, deregulating predatory industries, demolishing stigmatized neighborhoods and brutalizing minoritized communities.

among the very many things that should be said about the authoritarian moment is that it raises a lot of questions for critical urban scholars. it isn’t always debated as such. contemporary authoritarianism is by and large appearing at the national level and is usually not seen as an urban phenomenon. it is regarded as the embodiment of traditional conservative anti-urbanism or said to represent the supposed revenge of the small town against the big city (rossi citation2018). the resurgence of authoritarianism is imagined as something that happens to cities and does not emerge from them. but this is a serious simplification.

to a significant degree, the global wave of authoritarianism is an urban phenomenon. it was presaged by many different chapters in urban history. to take just one example, in the 1970s and 1980s some american urban voters turned towards a reactionary illiberalism and austerity (see, e.g., rieder citation1985; phillips-fein citation2017) and charismatic figures, like philadelphia mayor frank rizzo, who laid some of the ideological groundwork for contemporary authoritarianism (lombardo citation2018). today’s demagogues like donald trump, recep tayyip erdoğan and javier milei are thoroughly metropolitan characters, having grown up and established their careers in the big city. and while they draw some of their support from voters excluded by the neoliberal global economy centered upon these cities, they are more intimately connected to finance, real estate capital and other economic sectors that built the unequal global-urban order in the first place.

reactionary authoritarianism also draws on the more repressive versions of urban politics that came before it by incorporating a distinctly revanchist spatial imaginary. it defines itself in opposition to a deeply racialized picture of cityness imagined as heterogeneous, unruly and ungovernable. mobilizing a kind of greatest hits of racist and stigmatizing tropes from the past few decades, today’s reactionaries portray cities as chaotic collections of no-go zones, black lives matter protesters, uncontrollable urban gangs, foreign religious zealots, domestic secular cosmopolitans, and criminals coddled by supposedly left-wing municipal governments. this image of the city ties together a number of otherwise disparate ideological strands within authoritarian coalitions.

if the new authoritarianism encompasses a visceral and vicious territorial stigma, it also possesses its own twisted version of urban utopianism. combining economist paul romer’s idea of charter cities with ayn rand’s fantasy of elite secession, various groups of cryptocurrency scammers and silicon valley grifters are claiming they will create new techno-utopian cities ex nihilo. california forever, praxis and other shadowy initiatives are buying land and raising untold millions of dollars in funding in order to build what they promise to be unregulated zones where normal citizenship is permanently suspended. this is the urbanization of crack-up capitalism (slobodian citation2023), an ideological illusion that represents a predatory elite’s dream of a new kind of accelerated urban space with no democracy and no consequences.

editorial

There is no alternative to creating an alternative: critical urban studies in the authoritarian moment
"A Surveillance State?" by Alisdare Hickson, available on Wikimedia Commons under CC BY-SA 2.0.
abstract / preview

Abstract

There is no alternative to creating an alternative: critical urban studies in the authoritarian moment

As we finish preparing this issue for publication, Donald Trump is entertaining the prospect of ethnically cleansing Gaza and turning it into a ghoulish luxury resort. Domestically, his administration is working tirelessly to incapacitate the state, terrorize significant segments of America’s diverse working class and ultimately unleash a wave of repression within American cities. In other places where they have come to power, authoritarian governments are violently cracking down on opposition movements, pushing through extreme austerity, deregulating predatory industries, demolishing stigmatized neighborhoods and brutalizing minoritized communities. Among the very many things that should be said about the authoritarian moment is that it raises a lot of questions for critical urban scholars. It isn’t always debated as such. Contemporary authoritarianism is by and large appearing at the national level and is usually not seen as an urban phenomenon. It is regarded as the embodiment of traditional conservative anti-urbanism or said to represent the supposed revenge of the small town against the big city (Rossi Citation2018). The resurgence of authoritarianism is imagined as something that happens to cities and does not emerge from them. But this is a serious simplification.

read on t&f ↗

original articles

Sharing social reproduction in a housing commons: the case of La Borda in Barcelona
"La Borda building - front facade 1" by VELKEJ LED, available on Wikimedia Commons under CC BY-SA 4.0.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Sharing social reproduction in a housing commons: the case of La Borda in Barcelona

This paper advances research on housing commons by providing a deeper understanding of the political significance of the collectivisation of home-based reproductive work under post-2008 austerity. Examining how reproductive work is collectively organised in La Borda, a housing commons in Barcelona, I explore how the collectivisation of care and housework challenges the social reproduction regimes that sustain financialised capitalism. Post-2008 housing financialisation has been enabled by austerity policies that re-privatise social reproduction within the home-family nexus. This process underscores the need to investigate collective homemaking practices that prefigure equitable forms of social reproduction. To this end, the paper first situates housing commons, where care and housework are collectively shared, within feminist legacies of social reproduction, highlighting their renewed relevance amid austerity and financialisation. Against this backdrop, it empirically examines how the collectivisation of reproductive work in La Borda has strengthened community belonging and brought social value to traditionally devalued practices. While the distribution of reproductive work in this housing initiative remains far from equitable, I argue that dynamics such as security of tenure, space co-production, participatory democracy, and a feminist ethos have created conditions for renegotiating historical reproductive imbalances.

read on t&f ↗
The Barcelona imaginaries: a decade of digital politics
"Cocreació Decidim en economia a Procomuns 2017" by Mogams, available on Wikimedia Commons under CC BY-SA 4.0.
abstract / preview

Abstract

The Barcelona imaginaries: a decade of digital politics

Over the past decade and a half, Barcelona has been widely recognized as a ‘smart city’. Since 2015, it has also gained attention as a ‘rebel city’, with an alternative imaginary to that of the corporate smart city and, more broadly, others launched from Silicon Valley. This article analyzes a decade of opposing imaginaries around digital politics in the Catalan capital. It illustrates how Barcelona moved from a narrative of smartness to one of technological sovereignty and, from there, to one of technological humanism. These shifts went hand in hand with institutional innovations that reinforced, successively, the centrality of public-private, public-common, and, finally, public-private-community partnerships (with this latter model representing a return of the centrality of the public-private axis). Drawing on fieldwork and desk research, the article systematically maps numerous visions and projects associated with these three imaginaries. Finally, the study uses the case of Barcelona to understand recent changes in digital capitalism.

read on t&f ↗
Mediating urban realities: the role of real-estate appraisers in dismantling the Musha'a system
Figure: Initial empty plot and subsequent development plan in Tel Aviv's project.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Mediating urban realities: the role of real-estate appraisers in dismantling the Musha'a system

This paper examines the land titling process in Tel Aviv's Shapira neighborhood, highlighting the crucial role of real-estate appraisers in shaping the outcomes of Plan TA-4455. It challenges Hernando de Soto's claim that the shift from collective to private land ownership is a purely technical matter, revealing the deep socio-political influence of appraisers. Through qualitative research, including interviews and document analysis, the study shows how appraisers navigate complex land ownership scenarios, with their decisions directly impacting urban development and social equity. The paper critically engages with both proponents and critics of de Soto, arguing that the effects of land titling are neither inherently positive nor negative but are deeply political, shaped by the strategic choices made by these professionals. By positioning appraisers as central actors in the urban political landscape, this study underscores their significant role in determining who benefits from urban development and who is marginalized, offering a more politically engaged understanding of property rights reforms.

read on t&f ↗
Chronic peripheralization through urban (re)development in Bucharest: a study of spatial injustice
Figure: Plumbuita area (Source: Google Earth).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Chronic peripheralization through urban (re)development in Bucharest: a study of spatial injustice

European funds for urban development often turn into neighborhood surveillance and policing people in vulnerable situations, contributing to the racialized production of space in Bucharest. This article examines the intersection of urban regeneration programs (URPs) and post-socialist public-private dynamics, revealing how URPs preserve spatial injustice in marginalized urban areas. Tackling the case study of the Plumbuita neighborhood in Bucharest, the article explores how restitution laws, ecological neglect, local governance, and EU development funds deepen racial and class divisions. The article argues that the EU Cohesion Policy, intended to support urban development, instead reinforce racialization and marginalization, particularly of Roma communities. By diverting resources toward policing and surveillance rather than social and infrastructural development, URPs exacerbate poverty and exclusion, creating long-lasting spatial injustice. Thus, what was intended for economic, social, and territorial cohesion instead creates chronic peripheralization in certain urban areas. The analysis contributes to urban studies by demonstrating how local governance, legal ambiguities, and neoliberal policies maintain inequalities in urban settings, particularly in Eastern European cities.

read on t&f ↗
From the right to the city to the right to the village? French perspectives on the urban-rural divide
"Crasville-la-Rocquefort rural landscape" by Foxandpotatoes, available on Wikimedia Commons under CC BY-SA 3.0.
abstract / preview

Abstract

From the right to the city to the right to the village? French perspectives on the urban-rural divide

Within urban studies, the planetary extent of energy and material flows is increasingly questioned as a major cause of current ecological crises. Within degrowth movements and thinking, pleas for the relocalisation of humanity’s attachments are becoming common and, in France at least, they are often associated with anti-urban stances and calls to leave big cities and metropolises, considered to be the epicentres of planetary urbanisation and globalisation. This review essay presents this ecological critique that developed in France over the past decade. It starts with a fresh look at the right to the city. To what extent can big cities still embody an ideal at odds with urbanisation, as Henri Lefebvre posited? Does radicalism not lie more in the back-to-the-land calls that are re-flourishing? The essay then discusses the opposition between planetary urbanisation and relocalisation, and explores the recent French conversation on the ‘right to the village’. Beyond such a right, a crucial issue for degrowth, however radical its vision, is to ruralise the urban, particularly in large metropolitan regions.

read on t&f ↗
(En)countering (im)permanence: marginal home-making as critical urban practice
"Houses in informal settlement (6901419865)" by SuSanA Secretariat, available on Wikimedia Commons under CC BY 2.0.
abstract / preview

Abstract

(En)countering (im)permanence: marginal home-making as critical urban practice

In light of the substantial retrenchment of State involvement in pro-poor housing in the Global South, urban informal settlements have become home to half of its population. Conversely, post-independence Bangladesh has sustained a trajectory of providing subsidized housing for the marginalized demographics. In stark contrast to their predominantly informal habitation, the governmental approach in Bangladesh favors the provision of permanent housing/houses as its principal mode of delivery. Using a critical lens, we attempt to encounter this tendency within urban (neoliberal) discourses that view permanence as ‘the answer’ to marginal people’s home-making. Taking Bastuhara and Guccha-gram—two formal sector resettlement projects from Khulna, Bangladesh, we seek to identify marginal people’s alternative mode(s) of urban home-making, especially against the backdrop of the formal sector’s fondness for permanence. We argue that the entire housing scenario is founded on various conditions of ‘in-betweenness’, deliberately constructed by the state (and its colonia-influenced bureaucratic apparatus) that it uses for political control and own legitimization. In response, the displaced’s home-making practices instigate counter-acts in two different forms of in-betweenness—spatial and non-spatial temporalities and non-permanence. The grassroots politics and their alternative spatial practices resemble moments of counter-urbanism by working at the permanence-temporality intersection through their nuanced and silent acts of occupation/encroachment but without actually resisting the state's modus operandi.

read on t&f ↗
Social infrastructures as pillars of resistance against housing commodification in creative city Groningen
Figure: Groningen & Eemskanaal area (Source: De Veer Citation2024).
abstract / preview

Abstract

Social infrastructures as pillars of resistance against housing commodification in creative city Groningen

Accumulation strategies over the urban space increasingly target the emergent creative social strata through place-branding and urban transformation. In this article, we examine the role of squatting and urban commoning in creating resilient alternatives to housing commodification in Groningen, Netherlands. The COVA factory area, a communal space for artists, was targeted for ‘Stad aan het Water’ redevelopment scheme amid a shift towards creative city policies. Concurrently, the area transformed into an urban commons called ‘Betonbos’ squatted by urban artists. Countering the hegemony of neoliberal interests in the housing realm, street art communities turned to squatting and counter-branding to reclaim urban spaces. Through eleven qualitative walking interviews with urban artists, our research reveals how these movements resist commodification and foster an alternative creative city ethos. The Betonbos commons and its ally, Groningen Undercurrent, exemplify how collective action can cultivate empowering social infrastructures. By prioritizing shared governance and use-value, the Betonbos experience demonstrates the potential for a reimagined urban landscape beyond commodification. We foreground how grassroots movements such as Groningen Undercurrent work together to generate alternative social infrastructures grounded in spaces of resistance and struggles for a creative city framework that embraces diversity, inclusion, and the transformative power of collective action.

read on t&f ↗

special feature: decentring urban climate finance

Decentring urban climate finance. Introduction to the Special Feature
"BAPV solar-facade" by Hanjin, available on Wikimedia Commons under CC BY-SA 3.0.

decentring urban climate finance. introduction to the special feature

hanna hilbrandt, fritz-julius grafe, emma colven, sarah knuth, cs ponder, enora robin, zac taylor

keywords: climate finance, provincializing, urban adaptation, development finance, climate risk, racial capitalism

abstract / preview

Abstract

Decentring urban climate finance. Introduction to the Special Feature

Financial agendas centering on the global fight against climate change have increasingly turned to cities and urban re/development projects as ideal candidates for supposedly ‘future proof’ investment. In the last decade, research has witnessed the development of policy programs, risk assessments, and project pipelines, amongst other efforts to materialize this agenda in the city. Drawing on critical urban geographies of what is loosely known as ‘climate finance’, this Special Feature, ‘Decentering Urban Climate Finance’, proposes to expand and provincialize these dominant agendas. The five contributions in this Special Feature employ the notion of decentering in four distinct ways: by putting a broader range of theoretical lenses to use and rereading the workings of climate finance through them; by highlighting the modes of omission through which dominant understandings of climate finance narrow its operations to a limited set of solutions, approaches, places, and imaginaries; by turning a view onto under-examined sites of finance and climate adaptation; and by imagining alternative transformative imaginaries of urban climate finance.

read on t&f ↗
Centering work: toward more ‘social’ accounts of urban climate finance
"CDMX Programa Ambiental 2019-2024 03" by Gobierno de la Ciudad de México (uploaded by Anticeri), available on Wikimedia Commons under CC BY 4.0.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Centering work: toward more ‘social’ accounts of urban climate finance

In recent years, high-profile financial actors have developed a dizzying array of services and devices that promise to help cities devise ‘solutions’ to climate change. But what must happen for private finance to stand at the centre of urban climate solutionism, as these actors claim it does? This intervention suggests that placing private finance at the core of urban climate action requires a lot of work, which we refer to as centering work: the significant technical, political, and material efforts involved in making urban climate action—as a problem space, a set of technical competencies, or an emerging market—amenable to private finance intervention. Drawing on the interdisciplinary field of the Social Studies of Finance, we trace centering work through the case of the World Bank’s City Creditworthiness Initiative, and its implications for how urban officials understand, and act on, resilience around the world. We also discuss the value of centering work for future scholarship on urban climate governance and urban studies more broadly. On the one hand, following centering work enables researchers to observe how and why some urban climate pathways emerge to the exclusion of others. On the other hand, tracing centering work helps researchers to develop accounts of the politics of urban climate finance that are attuned to change.

read on t&f ↗
Making climate finance: toward everyday, historically informed, and reparative understandings
"HOLC security map of Philadelphia showing redlining of minority neighborhoods (1937)" by Home Owners' Loan Corporation / United States Federal Government, available on Wikimedia Commons in the Public Domain.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Making climate finance: toward everyday, historically informed, and reparative understandings

The centering of climate finance around a narrow set of institutions, sites, instruments, practices, and technologies is an achievement made possible by the domination of finance capital and policy elites. In this intervention, we shift the spotlight away from such elite projects and practices in favor of a wider understanding of urban climate finance—one that includes a more diverse set of sites, activities and participants. A wider and more inclusive conceptualization of urban climate finance requires accounting for the historical and ongoing role of finance in the production of climate vulnerability. Reconceptualized in this way, urban climate finance expands to include everyday financial life in cities around the world. Everyday climate finance is thus generated in places where the risks and uncertainties of climate change are currently unrecognized by policy elites as such, yet are being managed through improvised repertoires of financial practices. Additionally, (re)considering past financial practices as climate finance (e.g. historical residential redlining that produces climate vulnerability today), provides a rationale for demanding that past and present financial actors account for today’s climate injustices, and contribute to future reparative and abolitionist climate action.

read on t&f ↗

special feature: decentring urban climate financearticle

Understanding the functioning of urban climate finance through topologies of reach
"Recycling facility and Wind Turbine in Sunset Park 04" by CaptJayRuffins, available on Wikimedia Commons under CC BY 4.0.

understanding the functioning of urban climate finance through topologies of reach

fritz-julius grafe, giuseppe forino, arabella fraser, hanna hilbrandt, john hogan morris

keywords: urban climate finance, topologies, bankability, climate urbanism, adaptation finance

abstract / preview

Abstract

Understanding the functioning of urban climate finance through topologies of reach

Urban climate action is increasingly understood through the lens of finance: through financial agendas, interests, and practical tools which enable ‘bankable’ or profitable interventions. While the literature is rife with criticism of the normative foundations and exploitative effects of this approach, it fails to capture the variegated ways in which finance configures, and is configured by, particular urban sites and spaces of power. This contribution extends our cartography of urban climate finance by bringing to light the relational dynamics of financial practices and the ways in which they span across diverse urban sites in topological ways. It has now become a common refrain among development and finance institutions that urban climate finance is, in fact, difficult to realize. A central reason for this is the perceived lack of possibilities to generate returns for investors. A topological perspective offers a relational view on the spatial practices through which new places are to be enrolled into the use of climate finance with the aim of stabilizing financial investment. Concentrating on the notion of ‘topological reach’, we show how climate finance, through its particular demands for bankability, creates new urban presences through spatial mechanisms of stretches, folds and distortions. By examining these topological mechanisms across a breadth of empirical material sourced from the individual research of the coauthors, we unpack the ways in which climate finance strategies are extended by a limited set of actors across space, often dominating and instrumentalizing urban climate action imaginaries and practices, while also failing to address a wide range of concerns and communities which fall outside of the operational parameters and speculative horizons of finance. The topological perspective provides us with the tools to make these struggles visible and opens up avenues to contest contemporary climate finance practices on the ground and to decenter the overarching narratives that drive contemporary climate finance.

read on t&f ↗
Grappling with real property supremacy in US urban climate finance
"Home designed to resist flood waters" by FEMA / Joselyne Augustino, available on Wikimedia Commons in the Public Domain.
abstract / preview

Abstract

Grappling with real property supremacy in US urban climate finance

In US cities, drives to secure property value against climate risks have become a preoccupation for mainstream climate finance. This real property bias sidelines non-owners and inhabitants of historically marginalized housing types, limiting their capacity to prepare for and recover from climate change events. In this intervention, we survey major pathways of existing climate finance, before turning to emerging trends for residential ‘climate-proofing,’ retrofitting efforts that bring climate finance ‘home’ to the building level. Building on the concept of ‘real property supremacy,’ we demonstrate how resourcing climate response is limited by the privileging of real property in the structure and distribution of low-carbon financial tools and incentives. We argue that this privileging reproduces hierarchies of protection for some, while exacerbating existing social inequalities, exclusions, and predations for others—ultimately, yielding greater control over climate futures to those with asymmetrical power over real property. This structurally unequal treatment risks locking-in extant social hierarchies embedded in US real property relationships instead of seizing opportunities to transform them via the historic urban investments required for climate change.

read on t&f ↗
The ‘colorblindness’ of climate finance: how climate finance advances racial injustice in cities
Figure: Urban climate deal-making financing typologies (Source: Authors).

the ‘colorblindness’ of climate finance: how climate finance advances racial injustice in cities

sahar zavareh hofmann, c. s. ponder, héctor herrera, manuel de vera, akira drake rodriguez, kareem buyana

keywords: climate finance, racial capitalism, mindanao (philippines), mexico city, philadelphia

abstract / preview

Abstract

The ‘colorblindness’ of climate finance: how climate finance advances racial injustice in cities

The interactions between climate change and financial markets are increasingly becoming a topic of study, yet the ways in which climate finance reinforces new modes of racialization in urban climate adaptation projects remain an under-represented line of questioning in both academic and policy worlds. In order to uncover myriad processes of racialization occurring within financing modes that are mobilized to solve the climate crisis, this paper focuses on three different urban deal-making spaces: Cagayan De Oro City located in Mindanao, in the southern part of the Philippines; Mexico City, the capital of Mexico; and Philadelphia, PA, situated in the northeastern corridor of the United States. Through analysis of the financial deals structuring urban climate endeavors in these three different cultural and environmental milieus, we find that the ‘colorblindness’ of climate finance both reinforces historical environmental injustices and creates new spatialities of environmental racism through its reliance on structures of racial capitalism. In doing so we also show the relevance of the racial capitalism framework beyond its theoretical heartlands.

read on t&f ↗

scenes sounds action

Mise-en-Scène do Mercado
figure. Curtain Raise
abstract / preview

Abstract

Mise-en-Scène do Mercado

This photographic project focuses on three urban markets in Portugal, each undergoing different phases of renewal: Mercado de Arroios in Lisbon, Mercado do Bolhão in Porto, and Mercado dos Lavradores in Funchal. The aim was to document and catalogue the distinctive features and underlying character of these places while they were being subjected to significant alterations and changes. Extensive photographic investigations were conducted at the sites during a three-year period, involving numerous reconnaissance photo-walks. The work was inspired by Gordon Cullen’s investigative photographic explorations in towns and cities, which he collated in his seminal text Townscape (1961). This material provided a framework to navigate the complex interplay of forms, features and experiences that I encountered within each market.

read on t&f ↗
8000 cities: beyond the contested urbanisation of Addis Ababa
Chari village was expropriated and urbanised as part of the outward expansion of the capital, 2019. Source: Nafis Fathollahzadeh/© Author’s own.
abstract / preview

Abstract

8000 cities: beyond the contested urbanisation of Addis Ababa

The photo essay deals with Ethiopia's controversial urbanisation and the transformative spaces within the city. It explores various stages of urbanisation, the gradual transition from rural to urban spaces, inner-city migration, and the emergence and disappearance of different areas. The essay weaves together a network of exchanges through a series of images and a collection of conversations. It focuses on the rural-urban transformation in the eastern periphery of Addis Ababa, where geographical, ethnic, and social fault lines intersect. The narrative moves from the disappearing spaces on the eastern side of the Akaki Gorge to the emerging urban areas, including social housing settlements and gated communities of luxury villas. This photo series is part of the ‘Momentography of a Failure’ project, a collaboration between Ethiopian urbanists, professional and non-professional photographers, and residents of various neighbourhoods. The ‘Momentography of a Failure’ conducted a workshop that was part of the collaborative artistic research for the documentary film Rift Finfinnee (2020) by Daniel Kötter, and was led by Nafis Fathollahzadeh, Bisrat Kifle, Daniel Kötter, and the Center for Photography in Ethiopia (CPE).

read on t&f ↗

reviews

city: analysis of urban change, theory, action journal and website provide a conduit for critical academic debates and theoretical development, considering their implications for everyday lives, urban change and action.